Lesson planGardening Seed Soak Experiment: Does Soaking Speed Germination? Mean and MAD
Science50 minutesGrades: 6th, 7th
Overview
Test whether soaking seeds makes them sprout faster, with real stats.
Description
Your teen designs a fair test with 20 bean or pea seeds, soaking half overnight and leaving half dry, sprouts them in damp paper towels in zip-top bags, records the day each seed germinates over about a week, then compares the two groups using dot plots, means and mean absolute deviation.
Objective
Your teen will run a controlled germination experiment, calculate the mean and mean absolute deviation for each group, and express the difference between group means as a multiple of the MAD.
Standards
6.SP.5cMath · Grade 6 · Statistics & Probability Giving quantitative measures of center (median and/or mean) and variability (interquartile range and/or mean absolute deviation), as well as describing any overall pattern and any striking deviations from the overall pattern with reference to the context in which the data were gathered.
7.SP.3Math · Grade 7 · Statistics & Probability Informally assess the degree of visual overlap of two numerical data distributions with similar variabilities, measuring the difference between the centers by expressing it as a multiple of a measure of variability.
Materials
| Item | Quantity |
|---|
| Garden bean or pea seeds from a seed packet (or plain dried beans from the grocery store) | 20 or more |
| Paper towels | 4 |
| Zip-top sandwich bags | 2 |
| Small bowl of water | 1 |
| Permanent marker | 1 |
| Ruler | 1 |
| Germination data sheet from this lesson | 1 per teen |
Vocabulary
Germination
When a seed starts to grow; in this test, when the first root (radicle) pokes out of the seed coat.
Imbibition
A dry seed soaking up water and swelling, the first stage of germination.
Control group
The group that doesn't get the treatment, used for comparison.
Mean absolute deviation (MAD)
The average distance of each data value from the mean.
Variable
A factor that can change in an experiment.
Preparation
- The night before Day 1, put 10 seeds in a bowl of room-temperature water to soak for 8 to 12 hours (no longer than 24 hours). Keep 10 seeds dry.
- Copy the germination data sheet.
- Wash hands after handling seeds; treated seeds from some packets are coated with a fungicide (often pink, blue or green). Don't eat any experiment seeds.
Introduction
Say: "Some gardeners swear soaking seeds overnight makes them sprout faster. Others say it doesn't matter. How could we settle it with data instead of opinions?"
What does a seed need to start growing?
What would make this test unfair?
Steps
1Step 1
Design a fair test
(8 min) Day 1: Your teen writes a question, a hypothesis and the one variable being changed (soaking). They list what stays the same for both groups: seed type, number of seeds, towel, amount of water, bag and location.

2Step 2
Set up the bags
(10 min) Your teen wets two paper towels, wrings them until damp, and lays 10 soaked seeds on one and 10 dry seeds on the other, spaced apart. They fold each towel, slide it into a labeled zip-top bag left slightly open for air, and set both bags side by side in a warm spot out of direct sun.

3Step 3
Check daily
(10 min) Days 2 to 8: Each day (about 1 to 2 minutes), your teen opens the towels and records the day number on which each seed's root first appears, re-dampening the towel if needed. Seeds that never sprout by Day 8 are recorded as 'did not germinate' and left out of the mean, but counted in the germination rate.

4Step 4
Dot plots
(8 min) Final day: Your teen draws two dot plots on the same number line (days 1 to 8), one for soaked seeds and one for dry seeds, and describes the overlap they see. They note any seeds that never germinated beside each plot.

5Step 5
Mean, MAD and conclusion
(12 min) Your teen calculates the mean germination day and the MAD for each group, then divides the difference in means by the larger MAD. They write a conclusion explaining whether the difference is large compared with the variation, and what they'd change in a second trial.

Conclusion
Ask: did soaking make a real difference, or was it small compared with how much the seeds varied? How would a bigger sample change your confidence?
Make your own lesson plan in minutes
Describe a topic and Resource Portal AI writes the objectives, materials and steps for your group.
Try Resource Portal AI