Lesson plan

Harvest Corn Then and Now: Comparing Two Texts

Reading30 minutesGrades: K, 1st, 2nd
Harvest Corn Then and Now: Comparing Two Texts

Overview

Read two corn texts and compare them in a Venn diagram.

Description

Your child reads (or listens to) two short nonfiction texts about growing corn, one about Wampanoag corn gardens and one about a modern farm, then sorts picture cards into a two-circle diagram to show how growing corn is the same and different.

Objective

Your child will identify at least two similarities and two differences between two informational texts on the same topic.

Standards

RI.1.9ELA · Grade 1 · Reading: Informational Text
Identify basic similarities in and differences between two texts on the same topic (e.g., in illustrations, descriptions, or procedures).
RI.2.9ELA · Grade 2 · Reading: Informational Text
Compare and contrast the most important points presented by two texts on the same topic.
RI.K.9ELA · Grade K · Reading: Informational Text
With prompting and support, identify basic similarities in and differences between two texts on the same topic (e.g., in illustrations, descriptions, or procedures).

Materials

ItemQuantity
The two texts from the 'Read-aloud texts' section, copied or printed1 copy each
Large paper with two overlapping circles drawn on it1
Small paper squares for picture or word cards10
Crayons or pencils1 set
Optional: a real ear of corn or a bag of cornmeal1

Vocabulary

Compare
To tell how things are the same.
Contrast
To tell how things are different.
Cornmeal
Dried corn ground into a coarse powder for cooking.
Harvest
Gathering crops when they are ready.

Preparation

Introduction

Show your child an ear of corn or some cornmeal. Ask: 'People in this land have grown corn for thousands of years. Do you think they grew it the same way long ago and today?'
Where does the corn we eat come from?
What tools do you think a farmer uses?

Steps

1Step 1
Read text 1
(7 min) Read 'Corn in a Wampanoag Garden' together. After each paragraph, your child tells you one detail in their own words.
2Step 2
Read text 2
(7 min) Read 'Corn on a Farm Today' the same way. Ask your child to point to the sentence that tells how the corn is harvested.
3Step 3
Make detail cards
(7 min) Your child draws or writes one detail per paper square, such as 'plant in spring', 'mounds', 'tractor', 'harvest in fall' or 'cornmeal'. Make at least 8 cards between the two texts.
4Step 4
Sort and compare
(7 min) Your child places each card in the left circle, the right circle or the middle 'Both' space and explains why. Finish by saying one sentence about how they are the same and one about how they are different.

Conclusion

Ask: 'What is one thing both texts taught you about corn?' At Thanksgiving, look for corn foods on the table, like cornbread or corn on the cob, and share what you learned.

Make your own lesson plan in minutes

Describe a topic and Resource Portal AI writes the objectives, materials and steps for your group.

Try Resource Portal AI