Full lesson preview

North Pole or South Pole? Read Two Polar Animal Texts and Compare

Reading35 minutesGrades: 1st, 2nd
North Pole or South Pole? Read Two Polar Animal Texts and Compare

Overview

Compare two texts about the two coldest places on Earth.

Description

Your child reads two short nonfiction texts, one about the Arctic and one about Antarctica, then sorts animal cards onto a two-pole map and fills in a 'same and different' chart about the two places.

Objective

Your child will identify similarities and differences between two texts about the Arctic and Antarctica and use details from each text to sort polar animals by where they live.

Standards

RI.1.9ELA · Grade 1 · Reading: Informational Text
Identify basic similarities in and differences between two texts on the same topic (e.g., in illustrations, descriptions, or procedures).
RI.2.9ELA · Grade 2 · Reading: Informational Text
Compare and contrast the most important points presented by two texts on the same topic.

Materials

ItemQuantity
The two texts in the 'Read-aloud texts' section, printed or copied by hand1 copy each
Index cards or paper squares for animal cards8
Large paper for a two-circle map1 sheet
Crayons or markers1 set
Globe or world map (optional)1

Vocabulary

Arctic
The cold area at the top of the Earth, around the North Pole.
Antarctica
The icy continent at the bottom of the Earth, around the South Pole.
Continent
One of the seven very large areas of land on Earth.
Compare
To tell how things are the same and different.

Preparation

Introduction

Ask your child: do polar bears eat penguins? Let them guess, then tell them the answer is hiding in two texts you are going to read.
What do you already know about the North Pole or the South Pole?
Have you ever read two books about the same thing?

Steps

1Step 1
Read Text 1: The Arctic
(7 min) Read Text 1 together, taking turns sentence by sentence. Your child underlines or points to two facts about the land or the animals.
2Step 2
Read Text 2: Antarctica
(7 min) Read Text 2 the same way. If you have a globe, find the top and the bottom of the Earth and show how far apart the two places are.
3Step 3
Sort the animals
(8 min) Your child draws a quick picture on each animal card, then places it in the Arctic or Antarctica circle, looking back at the texts to check. Ask them to point to the sentence that proves each answer.
4Step 4
Same and different
(9 min) Make a list of things both texts say are true (both are very cold, both have ice, both have seals) and things that are different (land vs. frozen ocean, people live there vs. only visiting scientists, polar bears vs. penguins). Your child answers the hook question: polar bears and penguins never meet in the wild.

Conclusion

Ask your child to tell you one way the two texts were the same and one way they were different, using the words 'both' and 'but'.

Make your own lesson plan in minutes

Describe a topic and Resource Portal AI writes the objectives, materials and steps for your group.

Try Resource Portal AI