Lesson planSacagawea's Real Role: Two Accounts of the Lewis and Clark Expedition
Reading50 minutesGrades: 6th, 7th, 8th
Overview
Compare two accounts of Sacagawea and decide which the evidence supports.
Description
Your child compares two short accounts of Sacagawea's role on the Lewis and Clark expedition, a popular "she guided them across the continent" version and an evidence-based version, cites evidence from paraphrased expedition journals, and considers what the expedition meant for the Native nations whose homelands it crossed.
Objective
Your child will cite several pieces of textual evidence and analyze how two authors present Sacagawea's role differently, then explain the expedition's impact on Native nations.
Standards
RI.7.1ELA · Grade 7 · Reading: Informational Text Cite several pieces of textual evidence to support analysis of what the text says explicitly as well as inferences drawn from the text.
RI.7.9ELA · Grade 7 · Reading: Informational Text Analyze how two or more authors writing about the same topic shape their presentations of key information by emphasizing different evidence or advancing different interpretations of facts.
Materials
| Item | Quantity |
|---|
| Account A and Account B (in Additional Sections) | 1 each |
| Journal evidence cards (in Additional Sections) | 1 set |
| Two highlighters or colored pencils | 2 colors |
| Map of the western United States | 1 |
| Notebook and pencil | 1 |
Vocabulary
Interpreter
A person who translates spoken words from one language to another.
Homeland
The land a people has lived on and cared for over generations.
Primary source
A record made by someone who was there at the time, such as a journal.
Myth (historical)
A popular belief about the past that the evidence does not support.
Preparation
- Read both accounts, the evidence cards and the background section.
- Mark Fort Mandan (North Dakota), the Three Forks of the Missouri and Lemhi Pass (Montana-Idaho) and the Pacific coast near the Columbia River on the map.
- Optional: look up the Lemhi Shoshone Tribe's own perspective on Sacagawea (the Sacajawea Center in Salmon, Idaho, is a good starting point).
Introduction
Sacagawea is on a U.S. dollar coin and has more statues than almost any other American woman. Many people learned that she guided Lewis and Clark all the way across the continent. What does the evidence actually say?
Where did you first hear about Sacagawea, and what did it say?
Why might a story about a real person get simplified over time?
Whose homelands did the expedition travel through?
Steps
1Step 1
Read Account A
(8 min) Your child reads the popular-style Account A and highlights every claim about what Sacagawea did. Ask, "What impression does this author want you to have?" Jot the answer in the notebook.

2Step 2
Read Account B and the evidence cards
(12 min) Your child reads Account B and the paraphrased journal evidence cards, highlighting claims in a second color. They note which claims in each account are supported by the evidence cards and which are not.

3Step 3
Evidence chart
(12 min) Your child makes a three-column chart: Claim, Supported by (card number), Verdict (supported, partly supported, not supported). They fill in at least five claims, citing the specific card for each verdict.

4Step 4
Compare the authors
(8 min) Your child writes a paragraph explaining how the two authors shape Sacagawea's story differently, including what each emphasizes and what each leaves out. Push them to cite at least three pieces of evidence.

5Step 5
The bigger picture
(10 min) Trace the route on the map and discuss that the expedition crossed the homelands of dozens of Native nations who helped it survive with food, horses and directions. Talk about how the expedition opened the way for U.S. expansion, the fur trade and settlement that cost those nations much of their land, and how tribes such as the Lemhi Shoshone tell Sacagawea's story today.

Conclusion
Your child states in two sentences what Sacagawea's real contributions were, with evidence, and why the simplified version spread.
Make your own lesson plan in minutes
Describe a topic and Resource Portal AI writes the objectives, materials and steps for your group.
Try Resource Portal AI