Full lesson preview

Who Owns AI-Generated Art? A Class Debate

Language Arts1 HourGrades: 7th, 8th
Who Owns AI-Generated Art? A Class Debate

Overview

Students will explore the complex issue of AI-generated art ownership and engage in a structured debate to express their viewpoints.

Description

This lesson engages students in a debate on the ownership of AI-generated art, fostering critical thinking, collaboration, and communication skills. Students will work in groups to explore arguments and engage in respectful debate while developing their persuasive skills.

Objective

Students will understand the implications of AI in creative ownership and develop persuasive arguments to support their stance in a debate.

Standards

RI.7.8ELA · Grade 7 · Reading: Informational Text
Trace and evaluate the argument and specific claims in a text, assessing whether the reasoning is sound and the evidence is relevant and sufficient to support the claims.
SL.7.1ELA · Grade 7 · Speaking & Listening
Engage effectively in a range of collaborative discussions (one-on-one, in groups, and teacher-led) with diverse partners on grade 7 topics, texts, and issues, building on others' ideas and expressing their own clearly.
W.7.1ELA · Grade 7 · Writing
Write arguments to support claims with clear reasons and relevant evidence.

Materials

ItemQuantity
Argument Excerpts20 copies
Debate Role Cards20 cards
Markers30 pieces
Poster Boards5 pieces
Access to Computers/Tablets10 pieces
Claim-Counterclaim Paragraph Templates20 sheets

Vocabulary

AI (Artificial Intelligence)
Technology that simulates human intelligence processes, such as learning and problem-solving.
Meme
A humorous image, video, or text that is copied and spread rapidly by Internet users.
Ownership
The act of having control or possession of something.
Copyright
The legal right to control the use and distribution of creative works.
Intellectual Property
Creations of the mind, such as inventions, literary works, and designs.
Persuasion
The act of convincing someone to do or believe something.

Preparation

Introduction

Show AI-made 'Italian brainrot' characters and ask students to identify if they think they count as original art. What do you think makes an artwork original?
What do you think makes an artwork original?
Who should get credit for AI-generated art: the prompter, the AI company, or the artists whose work trained it?

Steps

1Step 1
Introduction to AI Art
(5 min) Begin by showing AI-made 'Italian brainrot' characters to the class. Ask students to identify if they think these characters can be considered original art. Encourage students to share their initial thoughts on what makes art original. No materials are needed for this step.
Step 1
2Step 2
Reading Arguments
(10 min) Distribute 20 copies of the Argument Excerpts to each student. The teacher says, "Take your time to read through these arguments carefully." Students will read and highlight key points that resonate with their own views. After reading, they will jot down their thoughts on how these arguments relate to their own stance on AI-generated art.
Step 2
3Step 3
Group Organization
(5 min) Organize students into 5 groups of 4, and hand out the Debate Role Cards. The teacher explains, "Each of you will take on a specific role to ensure a balanced debate." Students will discuss their roles within their groups and clarify any questions they have about their positions to prepare for the debate.
Step 3
4Step 4
Conducting the Debate
(25 min) Facilitate the debate by having students discuss who should get credit for AI-generated art: the prompter, the AI company, or the artists whose work trained it. The teacher sets a timer for 15 minutes for the debate and says, "Remember to listen respectfully and provide evidence for your claims." Each group will use 1 Poster Board and 6 Markers to summarize their arguments, creating a visual representation of their points. At the end of the debate, groups will share their findings with the class.
Step 4
5Step 5
Writing Reflections
(10 min) Each student will use the Claim-Counterclaim Paragraph Templates to write a paragraph reflecting on what they learned during the debate. The teacher encourages, "Think about both sides of the argument as you write your reflection." Students will draft a clear paragraph that includes their main argument and addresses counterarguments they encountered, ensuring a comprehensive understanding of the topic. No additional materials are required for this step.
Step 5
6Step 6
Class Reflection
(5 min) Conclude the lesson by having students share their reflections with the class. Each student will write 2 sentences about how their views on AI-generated art ownership may have changed after the debate. The teacher prompts, "Consider how your peers' arguments influenced your perspective." No materials are needed for this final reflection.
Step 6

Conclusion

In the reflection, students will share their thoughts on the debate about AI-generated art ownership. They will discuss the different perspectives they encountered and how their views may have changed after hearing from their peers.

Make your own lesson plan in minutes

Describe a topic and Resource Portal AI writes the objectives, materials and steps for your group.

Try Resource Portal AI