Lesson plan

Was Anna Jarvis Right? A Mother's Day Commercialization Seminar

Language Arts45 minutesGrades: 7th, 8th
Was Anna Jarvis Right? A Mother's Day Commercialization Seminar

Overview

Evaluate the founder's argument against a commercial Mother's Day.

Description

Your teen learns that the founder of Mother's Day spent her later years fighting the holiday's commercialization, traces and evaluates her argument and a modern counterargument, and leads a short family seminar where everyone must respond to new evidence before deciding how to celebrate.

Objective

Your teen will trace and evaluate the claims and reasoning in two short arguments, prepare evidence-based discussion points, and participate in a seminar where they acknowledge others' ideas and qualify or justify their own view.

Standards

RI.7.8ELA · Grade 7 · Reading: Informational Text
Trace and evaluate the argument and specific claims in a text, assessing whether the reasoning is sound and the evidence is relevant and sufficient to support the claims.
SL.7.1aELA · Grade 7 · Speaking & Listening
Come to discussions prepared, having read or researched material under study; explicitly draw on that preparation by referring to evidence on the topic, text, or issue to probe and reflect on ideas under discussion.
SL.7.1dELA · Grade 7 · Speaking & Listening
Acknowledge new information expressed by others and, when warranted, modify their own views.
SL.8.1dELA · Grade 8 · Speaking & Listening
Acknowledge new information expressed by others, and, when warranted, qualify or justify their own views in light of the evidence presented.

Materials

ItemQuantity
The two argument passages (in the sections below), printed or on a screen1 per person
Pencil and 2 colors of highlighter1 set
Index cards for discussion notes4 per person
Timer1

Vocabulary

Commercialization
Turning something into a way to sell products and make money.
Reasoning
The logic that connects evidence to a claim.
Qualify
To limit or adjust a claim to make it more accurate, such as 'mostly' instead of 'always.'
Seminar
A discussion where participants use evidence to explore a question together.

Preparation

Introduction

Say: the woman who created Mother's Day later tried to get it removed from the calendar. Ask: why would someone fight against the holiday she started?
Where do you see Mother's Day or Father's Day advertising each year?
Can a holiday be both heartfelt and commercial?

Steps

1Step 1
Background
(5 min) Your teen reads the About section and the Jarvis background in Argument A. They summarize in one sentence what Anna Jarvis wanted the day to be.
2Step 2
Trace the arguments
(12 min) Your teen reads Argument A and Argument B, highlighting each claim in one color and its supporting reasons or evidence in another. For each argument they write on a card: the claim, the best reason, and one weakness, such as a reason without evidence or an overgeneralization.
3Step 3
Prepare to discuss
(6 min) Your teen writes their own position on a card and two pieces of evidence from the passages. They also write one question to ask the group, using the Seminar questions as models.
4Step 4
Hold the seminar
(15 min) Your teen opens the seminar with the central question: should families celebrate Mother's and Father's Day the way Anna Jarvis wanted? Each speaker must connect to the previous speaker by name, and at least once everyone must say 'That makes me rethink...' or 'I still think..., because...' with evidence.
5Step 5
Reflect
(5 min) Your teen writes 3 sentences: their position now, one idea from someone else that changed or sharpened it, and how your family will celebrate this year as a result. Share the reflections aloud if everyone agrees.

Conclusion

Ask: did your position change, stay the same or become more qualified? Plan one way to celebrate a caregiver this year that Anna Jarvis might have approved of, like a handwritten letter.

Make your own lesson plan in minutes

Describe a topic and Resource Portal AI writes the objectives, materials and steps for your group.

Try Resource Portal AI