Full lesson preview

Who Ate the Cookies? A Detective Read-Aloud with Clue Questions

Reading30 minutesGrades: K, 1st, 2nd
Who Ate the Cookies? A Detective Read-Aloud with Clue Questions

Overview

Track the clues in a cookie mystery story.

Description

You read an original short mystery about missing cookies, pausing at each clue so your child can record it on a clue card; then your child answers who, what, where and why questions and uses the clues to explain the surprising solution.

Objective

Your child will ask and answer questions about key details in a mystery story and describe the characters, setting and major events using the clues.

Standards

RL.1.1ELA · Grade 1 · Reading: Literature
Ask and answer questions about key details in a text.
RL.1.3ELA · Grade 1 · Reading: Literature
Describe characters, settings, and major events in a story, using key details.
RL.2.1ELA · Grade 2 · Reading: Literature
Ask and answer such questions as who, what, where, when, why, and how to demonstrate understanding of key details in a text.
RL.K.1ELA · Grade K · Reading: Literature
With prompting and support, ask and answer questions about key details in a text.

Materials

ItemQuantity
The read-aloud story (in this lesson)1 copy
Index cards or paper squares for clue cards6 per child
Crayons or pencils1 per child
Cookies or crackers for a snack (optional)1-2 per child

Vocabulary

Clue
A piece of information that helps solve a mystery.
Evidence
Clues that show what really happened.
Setting
Where and when a story happens.
Solution
The answer to the mystery or problem.

Preparation

Introduction

Hold up an empty plate and say with a shocked face: the cookies are gone! Today you will help two kid detectives solve a cookie mystery.
What do detectives look for?
If cookies disappeared, who might have taken them?

Steps

1Step 1
Meet the story
(4 min) Read the first part of the story, up to where Leo cries that someone ate the cookies. Stop and ask: who are the characters, and where does the story happen?
2Step 2
Collect the clues
(10 min) Keep reading and stop after each clue. Your child draws or writes that clue on a numbered card, such as no crumbs, the floury handprint, the clean cat whiskers and the cookie smell.
3Step 3
Make a detective guess
(5 min) Before the ending, line up the 4 clue cards. Ask: who do you think took the cookies, and which clue makes you think so? Your child draws their guess on a blank card.
4Step 4
Read the solution
(4 min) Read the ending. Talk about which clues pointed to Grandma Rosa moving the cookies and which clue showed it was not the cat.
5Step 5
Answer the case questions
(6 min) Ask the case questions in this lesson. Your child answers out loud and holds up the clue card that proves each answer.

Conclusion

Ask your child to retell the mystery using the clue cards in order. Good readers and good detectives both pay attention to details.

Make your own lesson plan in minutes

Describe a topic and Resource Portal AI writes the objectives, materials and steps for your group.

Try Resource Portal AI