Full lesson preview

Automation Then and Now: What History Teaches About AI and Jobs

Social Studies50 minutesGrades: 11th
Automation Then and Now: What History Teaches About AI and Jobs

Overview

Compare the Luddites' fears with today's AI job debate.

Description

Your teen reads four short source cards on the Luddite frame-breakers of 1811 to 1816, the power loom, the ATM and the spreadsheet, plus Lord Byron's 1812 House of Lords speech on the Frame-Work Bill as a primary source. They build a two-column chart of fears versus outcomes, note where the sources disagree, and write a paragraph predicting which jobs AI might change and how.

Objective

Your teen will integrate information from primary and secondary sources into a coherent understanding of how earlier waves of automation affected work, noting discrepancies among sources, and apply it to current debates about AI and jobs.

Standards

RH.11-12.9ELA · Grade 11-12 · Reading in History/Social Studies (Literacy in History)
Integrate information from diverse sources, both primary and secondary, into a coherent understanding of an idea or event, noting discrepancies among sources.

Materials

ItemQuantity
Printed Source Cards A to D (from Additional Sections)1 set
Printed excerpt or summary of Lord Byron's 1812 maiden speech in the House of Lords on the Frame-Work Bill (public domain, free online)1
Notepad1
Pencil1
Printed old illustration of a weaving mill or power loom (public domain image search)1

Vocabulary

Luddites
English textile workers who, from 1811 to 1816, smashed machines they blamed for lowering wages and replacing skilled work; today the word is often misused to mean anyone who dislikes technology.
Automation
Using machines or software to do tasks people used to do.
Augmentation
Technology that helps a worker do a job better or faster without replacing the worker.
Primary source
A document or object created at the time being studied, such as a speech given in 1812.

Preparation

Introduction

Show the mill illustration. In 1812 the British Parliament made breaking stocking frames a crime punishable by death. Ask: what would make workers so angry at machines that they risked that, and are any of their fears the same as today's worries about AI?
What jobs do you think AI will change most in the next 10 years?
Is a fear wrong just because things turned out okay in the long run, or can it be right for the people living through it?

Steps

1Step 1
Read the sources
(15 min) Your teen reads Source Cards A to D and the Byron speech printout, marking with the pencil each source's main claim and who wrote it or what kind of source it is. For the Byron speech they note in the notepad what he says caused the frame-breaking and whose side he takes.
Step 1
2Step 2
Build the fears and outcomes chart
(12 min) On the notepad your teen draws a two-column chart with Fears on the left and What Happened on the right, with a row for each technology: stocking frame, power loom, ATM, spreadsheet and AI (outcome column left blank for AI). Each cell cites which source card the information came from.
Step 2
3Step 3
Find the discrepancies
(10 min) Your teen compares how Source Card A (the mill owner's view) and the Byron speech describe the same events, and how Source Card C's long-run numbers fit with the short-run suffering in Card B. They write two discrepancies in the notepad and explain why sources from different viewpoints or time scales disagree.
Step 3
4Step 4
Write the prediction paragraph
(13 min) Using the chart, your teen writes a 150 to 200 word paragraph in the notepad predicting which kinds of jobs AI is likely to change and whether through automation or augmentation, supported by at least three of the sources. They finish with one sentence on what history suggests about who bears the costs of the change.
Step 4

Conclusion

Ask: 'History says the economy usually created new jobs, but the Luddites still lost theirs. What would a fair plan for AI look like for the workers in between?'

Make your own lesson plan in minutes

Describe a topic and Resource Portal AI writes the objectives, materials and steps for your group.

Try Resource Portal AI