Lesson planWhat Ended the Age of Dinosaurs? An Evidence-Based Argument
Writing50 minutesGrades: 6th, 7th, 8th
Overview
Weigh the evidence and argue what wiped out the dinosaurs.
Description
Your teen sorts real evidence cards about the end-Cretaceous mass extinction (the iridium layer, shocked quartz, the Chicxulub crater, the Deccan Traps volcanoes) and writes a short argument essay that states a claim, supports it with evidence and reasoning, and addresses the main competing explanation.
Objective
Your teen will evaluate scientific evidence, write a clear claim about the cause of the end-Cretaceous extinction, support it with relevant evidence and reasoning, and acknowledge and respond to a counterclaim.
Standards
Support claim(s) with clear reasons and relevant evidence, using credible sources and demonstrating an understanding of the topic or text.
Introduce claim(s), acknowledge alternate or opposing claims, and organize the reasons and evidence logically.
Support claim(s) with logical reasoning and relevant evidence, using accurate, credible sources and demonstrating an understanding of the topic or text.
Support claim(s) with logical reasoning and relevant evidence, using accurate, credible sources and demonstrating an understanding of the topic or text.
Materials
| Item | Quantity |
|---|
| Evidence cards in this lesson, printed and cut apart or read from a screen | 1 set per teen or pair |
| Two sheets of paper labeled "Asteroid impact" and "Volcanic eruptions" | 1 each |
| Notebook paper or a laptop for writing | 1 |
| Highlighter | 1 |
Vocabulary
Mass extinction
A short period in geologic time when a large share of Earth's species die out.
K-Pg boundary
The thin rock layer marking the end of the Cretaceous and start of the Paleogene, about 66 million years ago.
Iridium
A metal that is rare in Earth's crust but more common in many asteroids.
Counterclaim
An opposing argument that a writer acknowledges and responds to.
Flood basalt
A huge series of lava eruptions that cover a large area, like India's Deccan Traps.
Preparation
- Print and cut out the evidence cards, or copy them into a document.
- Set out the two labeled sheets for sorting.
Introduction
Read this aloud: "About 66 million years ago, roughly three-quarters of all plant and animal species on Earth disappeared in a geological instant. Every non-bird dinosaur was gone." Ask: "If you were a detective, what clues would you look for in the rocks?"
What makes evidence strong rather than weak?
Can more than one cause contribute to the same event?
Steps
1Step 1
Sort the evidence
(10 min) Your teen reads each evidence card and places it on the "Asteroid impact" sheet, the "Volcanic eruptions" sheet, or between them if it fits both. They highlight the single strongest piece of evidence for each side.
2Step 2
Write a claim
(5 min) Your teen writes a one-sentence claim that answers the question, such as naming a main cause and any contributing cause. Check that it is arguable and specific rather than a plain fact.
3Step 3
Plan reasons and evidence
(10 min) Your teen outlines two body paragraphs, each with a reason, at least two evidence cards and an explanation of how that evidence supports the claim. They plan one counterclaim paragraph that fairly states the other side and responds with evidence.
4Step 4
Draft the essay
(18 min) Your teen writes a 4-5 paragraph argument: introduction with claim, two reasons, counterclaim and response, and a conclusion. Encourage transition words such as furthermore, however and this suggests.
5Step 5
Peer check
(7 min) Swap essays with a parent or sibling, who uses the checklist to underline the claim, number the evidence and star the counterclaim. Your teen revises one paragraph based on the feedback.
Conclusion
Ask: what evidence would change your mind? Most scientists today consider the Chicxulub impact the main trigger, while research continues on how much the Deccan Traps added stress before and after.
Make your own lesson plan in minutes
Describe a topic and Resource Portal AI writes the objectives, materials and steps for your group.
Try Resource Portal AI