Lesson plan

Earth Day Argument Essay: Should Our City Ban Single-Use Plastic Foodware?

Writing50 minutesGrades: 7th, 8th
Earth Day Argument Essay: Should Our City Ban Single-Use Plastic Foodware?

Overview

Write a balanced argument about banning single-use plastic.

Description

Your teen reads a short, balanced fact sheet about single-use plastic straws, utensils and foam containers, takes a side on whether their city should ban them completely, and writes an argument essay that supports the claim with evidence and fairly answers a counterclaim.

Objective

Your teen will introduce a claim, acknowledge and answer an opposing claim, support the claim with relevant evidence and logical reasoning, and connect ideas with transitions.

Standards

W.7.1aELA · Grade 7 · Writing
Introduce claim(s), acknowledge alternate or opposing claims, and organize the reasons and evidence logically.
W.7.1bELA · Grade 7 · Writing
Support claim(s) with logical reasoning and relevant evidence, using accurate, credible sources and demonstrating an understanding of the topic or text.
W.7.1cELA · Grade 7 · Writing
Use words, phrases, and clauses to create cohesion and clarify the relationships among claim(s), reasons, and evidence.

Materials

ItemQuantity
Fact sheet from the Additional Sections, printed or on screen1 per teen
Lined paper or a laptop1 per teen
Two highlighters in different colors1 set per teen
Single-use plastic items from the kitchen drawer (straw, fork, takeout container) as props2-3

Vocabulary

Claim
The position the writer argues for.
Counterclaim
An opposing position that a fair writer acknowledges.
Rebuttal
The writer's response showing why the counterclaim is weaker.
Single-use plastic
Plastic items made to be used once and thrown away.

Preparation

Introduction

Set the plastic fork, straw and takeout container on the table and ask: how many minutes did we use these? Plastic can last for hundreds of years. On Earth Day, many cities debate rules about plastic. Today your teen will take a side and argue it like a lawmaker.
Who would be helped by a ban? Who might be hurt?
What evidence would change your mind?

Steps

1Step 1
Read the fact sheet
(8 min) Your teen reads the fact sheet and highlights evidence that supports a ban in one color and evidence against a full ban in the other. They note any fact that surprised them.
2Step 2
Choose a claim
(5 min) Your teen decides on a claim: the city should ban single-use plastic foodware completely, or the city should keep the current state rules (items only on request) instead of a full ban. They write the claim as one clear sentence.
3Step 3
Outline
(12 min) Your teen outlines an introduction with the claim, two body paragraphs with a reason and evidence each, a counterclaim paragraph with a rebuttal, and a conclusion. Each piece of evidence gets a sentence explaining how it supports the claim.
4Step 4
Draft
(15 min) Your teen drafts the essay from the outline, using transitions such as although, on the other hand, as a result, and for this reason. They aim for five paragraphs of about 350-450 words.
5Step 5
Review and revise
(8 min) Read the essay aloud together. Check that the counterclaim is stated fairly, that every piece of evidence is explained, and circle each transition; add transitions where the ideas jump.

Conclusion

Ask: what was the strongest point on the other side, and how did you answer it? Encourage your teen to share the essay in a class, a school newspaper, or as public comment at a city council meeting.

Make your own lesson plan in minutes

Describe a topic and Resource Portal AI writes the objectives, materials and steps for your group.

Try Resource Portal AI