Full lesson preview

The Gettysburg Address: Comparing a Speech and a Historian's Account

Social Studies55 minutesGrades: 8th
The Gettysburg Address: Comparing a Speech and a Historian's Account

Overview

Compare Lincoln's own words with a historian-style account.

Description

Your teen reads Abraham Lincoln's complete Gettysburg Address of November 19, 1863, side by side with a short secondary account written for this lesson. They sort what each source offers on a Venn diagram, find where the secondary source interprets Lincoln's words, and write a paragraph explaining what each source can and cannot tell a reader.

Objective

Your teen will analyze the relationship between a primary source (the Gettysburg Address) and a secondary source on the same event, identifying what each provides, where the secondary source adds context or interpretation, and how the two support each other.

Standards

RH.6-8.9ELA · Grade 6-8 · Reading in History/Social Studies (Literacy in History)
Analyze the relationship between a primary and secondary source on the same topic.

Materials

ItemQuantity
Printed copy of the Source Packet (from this lesson)1
Highlighters in two colors2
Sheet of paper for a Venn diagram1
Sheets of lined paper2
Pencil1 per teen
Phone or kitchen timer1

Vocabulary

Primary source
A document or object created at the time of an event by someone who took part in or witnessed it.
Secondary source
An account written later by someone who studied primary sources and explains or interprets them.
Consecrate
To declare something sacred or set apart for an honored purpose.
Four score
Eighty years; a 'score' is twenty, so 'four score and seven' is 87 years.
Interpretation
An explanation of what something means, which goes beyond simply stating facts.

Preparation

Introduction

On November 19, 1863, the main speaker at Gettysburg talked for about two hours. Abraham Lincoln then spoke for about two minutes, and his speech is the one Americans still memorize. What can his words tell us that a later historian cannot, and the other way around?
If you were writing about an event 150 years ago, why would you want both the original words and a later explanation?
What might a later writer know that Lincoln did not know in 1863?

Steps

1Step 1
Do the math and read aloud
(8 min) Your teen figures out on the first of the 2 sheets of lined paper what year 'four score and seven years' before 1863 points to (1776) and why Lincoln chose it. Then they read the full speech in the 1 printed Source Packet aloud, slowly, once.
2Step 2
Mark up the primary source
(10 min) Your teen rereads the speech with the yellow highlighter, marking every phrase about the past, and the second highlighter for every phrase about what the living must do in the future. They count how many times Lincoln uses the words 'dedicate' or 'dedicated' and write the number in the margin.
3Step 3
Read the secondary account
(8 min) Your teen reads the Secondary Account and underlines facts that do not appear anywhere in Lincoln's speech, such as the date of the battle, Edward Everett, and the number of casualties. They put a star next to every sentence that interprets the speech rather than reporting a fact.
4Step 4
Fill the Venn diagram
(12 min) On the 1 Venn diagram sheet, your teen writes what only the primary source offers (Lincoln's exact words and tone), what only the secondary source offers (context, numbers, later meaning) and what both share. Set the 1 timer for 12 minutes and aim for at least four entries per section.
5Step 5
Answer the questions
(9 min) Your teen answers the Comparison Questions, quoting from both sources. You check against the Answer guide, especially Question 4 about whether the secondary source's interpretation is supported by Lincoln's words.
6Step 6
Write the relationship paragraph
(8 min) On the second sheet of lined paper your teen writes one paragraph: 'The Gettysburg Address and the secondary account work together because...' using one quotation from each source and the checklist in Additional Sections.

Conclusion

Ask your teen: 'If the only source you had was the secondary account, what would you lose? If you only had the speech, what would confuse a reader today?'

Make your own lesson plan in minutes

Describe a topic and Resource Portal AI writes the objectives, materials and steps for your group.

Try Resource Portal AI