Lesson plan

Enemies to Lovers, 1813: The First Proposal in Pride and Prejudice

Reading55 minutesGrades: 10th
Enemies to Lovers, 1813: The First Proposal in Pride and Prejudice

Overview

The original enemies-to-lovers scene, read line by line.

Description

Your teen reads chapter 34 of Pride and Prejudice (1813), where Mr. Darcy's first proposal goes spectacularly wrong, and tracks with colored tabs how each character's pride and prejudice show up in what they say and how they react. They compare the scene with a modern enemies-to-lovers trope checklist and write a paragraph on how the two characters' flaws drive the conflict and push the plot forward.

Objective

Your teen will analyze how Darcy and Elizabeth's conflicting motivations shape their exchange in chapter 34, how the scene advances the plot, and how it fits or breaks a modern trope.

Standards

RL.9-10.3ELA · Grade 9-10 · Reading: Literature
Analyze how complex characters (e.g., those with multiple or conflicting motivations) develop over the course of a text, interact with other characters, and advance the plot or develop the theme.

Materials

ItemQuantity
Pride and Prejudice, chapter 34 (any edition; free public-domain copies are online, for example at Project Gutenberg)1 copy
Sticky tabs in two colors1 pack each
Highlighter1
Notebook1
Index card for the trope checklist1

Vocabulary

Trope
A familiar pattern or device that shows up across many stories, such as enemies-to-lovers or the chosen one.
Free indirect discourse
Austen’s technique of blending the narrator’s voice with a character’s thoughts, so we hear a character’s feelings without quotation marks.
Pride
A high opinion of oneself or one’s position. In the novel, it can be a flaw (arrogance) or a fair self-respect.
Prejudice
A judgment formed before knowing the facts. Elizabeth’s quick judgments of Darcy are a form of it.

Preparation

Introduction

Ask your teen to name the enemies-to-lovers books or shows they know and list the beats they always hit: the insult, the forced proximity, the big fight, the confession. Then tell them they are about to read one of the scenes that helped invent the pattern, written in 1813.
What makes a fight between two characters feel like it will turn into romance?
Can a character be proud and still be the hero?

Steps

1Step 1
Set up and read
(15 min) Your teen reads chapter 34 aloud or silently, placing one color of sticky tab at every moment Darcy's pride shows and the other color at every moment Elizabeth's prejudice or anger drives her words. They highlight Darcy's opening line, "You must allow me to tell you how ardently I admire and love you," and the sentence where he explains why he struggled against his feelings.
2Step 2
Track the motivations
(10 min) In the notebook, your teen makes a two-column chart titled What Darcy wants / What Darcy fears and What Elizabeth wants / What Elizabeth believes, filling each with evidence from their tabs. They note at least one place where a character has two motivations pulling in different directions.
3Step 3
Map the turning points
(8 min) Your teen lists the three moments where the conversation escalates, such as when Elizabeth raises her sister Jane and Mr. Wickham, and explains how each one changes what happens next in the plot. They answer the discussion questions in Additional Sections.
4Step 4
Compare with the trope
(7 min) Your teen checks the scene against the trope checklist on the index card, marking which modern beats Austen uses and which she skips or twists. They write two sentences on what this scene does that many modern versions do not.
5Step 5
Write the analysis paragraph
(15 min) Your teen writes a paragraph in the notebook on how Darcy's and Elizabeth's flaws drive the conflict in chapter 34 and push the plot forward, quoting at least two short lines as evidence. They compare it with the model paragraph and the checklist and revise once.

Conclusion

Ask your teen whether they think Darcy deserved the rejection and whether Elizabeth was entirely fair. Great characters are the ones we keep arguing about two centuries later.

Make your own lesson plan in minutes

Describe a topic and Resource Portal AI writes the objectives, materials and steps for your group.

Try Resource Portal AI